UnitedHealth sues over 2027 Medicare Advantage ratings
UnitedHealth Group has sued the federal government over its 2027 Medicare Advantage star ratings, asking a federal court in Brunswick, Georgia, to set aside ratings it says were calculated using measures the agency had no authority to apply or did not allow the company to challenge. The case is pending, and no court has ruled on UnitedHealth’s claims.
The complaint says the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services improperly used 26 measures in calculating the ratings. UnitedHealth argues CMS either lacked legal authority to use them, failed to give the company an opportunity to object, or both. Reuters-origin reporting says the challenge covers 45 contracts; another account says 51 contracts. The difference is unresolved in the reporting.
UnitedHealth says correcting the calculations would raise the affected contracts’ ratings by at least half a star and as much as one and a half stars. Those are the company’s estimates in its complaint, not findings by a court. The company’s dollar estimate of any lost bonus payments was not reported.
The ratings use a one-to-five-star scale and measures including preventive care, customer satisfaction and other aspects of plan performance....