Global Edition
Global Edition
UK Edition
EU Edition
US Edition

Understand the story, not the spin.

Markets

Massachusetts high court to hear Clancy bid to dismiss case

Published 20 November 2026 · All stories from this day

The Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court will consider Lindsay Clancy’s petition to dismiss her case before a scheduled retrial, after a single justice referred the matter to the full court. Oral arguments are expected in January, and the retrial is scheduled to begin March 29, 2027, unless the court grants her request.

Clancy’s lawyers argue that trying her again would violate double-jeopardy protections. They say the judge overseeing her first trial should have questioned a holdout juror further before declaring a mistrial, and that additional inquiry could have provided an alternative to ending the trial without a verdict.

Judge William Sullivan rejected that argument, ruling that the court had acted properly in limiting its inquiry. He said further questioning of the holdout could have had a coercive effect. Sullivan also denied defense requests for records relating to the juror, including records from jury selection and deliberations and the juror’s phone records.

The petition challenges Sullivan’s rejection of Clancy’s motion to dismiss. The full Supreme Judicial Court’s review will address whether the defense’s double-jeopardy argument warrants dismissing the case before...

Now playing
0:00 / 0:00