Judge Keeps Alex Murdaugh Murder Indictments in Place
South Carolina Circuit Judge Debra McCaslin on November 20, 2026, denied Alex Murdaugh’s motion to dismiss the murder indictments against him, finding that the remaining evidence supported probable cause even if disputed grand jury testimony were excluded. The ruling leaves the indictments in place and the retrial scheduled for April 5, 2027, in Sumter County.
Murdaugh’s lawyers argued that former South Carolina Law Enforcement Division investigator David Owen misled the grand jury about blood evidence on a shirt Murdaugh wore and ammunition found at the family’s property. McCaslin found serious oversights in Owen’s handling of a laboratory report, but said the record did not establish that he knowingly gave false testimony or acted in bad faith.
The report, addressed to Owen, found no human blood in tested samples from the shirt. McCaslin said Owen failed to account for it before testifying to the grand jury. She criticized the failure, writing that such oversights undermine public confidence in the justice system, but concluded it did not justify dismissing the indictments.
The defense also challenged Owen’s account of shotgun ammunition. According to the ruling, no recovered...