Columbus and Roebuck dispute Home Alone screen test
Director Chris Columbus and actor Daniel Roebuck have given conflicting accounts of the circumstances surrounding Roebuck’s departure from the role of Marv in Home Alone, with the dispute centered on whether he screen-tested with Joe Pesci.
Columbus discussed the casting on the Wildmen podcast, saying he had initially wanted Daniel Stern and Pesci to play the burglars Marv and Harry. He said the studio would pay for only one of them, so he chose Pesci for Harry and cast another actor as Marv. Columbus said a screen test went poorly and that he fired the actor, whom he described as a young performer. He did not name Roebuck during the podcast.
Roebuck has identified himself as the actor who was let go. He has disputed Columbus’s account of the process, saying the filmmakers tried to make him quit. Roebuck also says he never filmed a screen test with Pesci and that the camera never rolled on the two actors together. He has said he spent one day with Pesci.
The accounts leave a specific point unresolved: Columbus described a screen test, while Roebuck denies that he and Pesci filmed one together. No test footage or production record is cited in the accounts. Columbus’s assessment of...