UK tribunal rejects secrecy over reported Apple data order
The Investigatory Powers Tribunal ruled that the UK government could not keep secret a reported order requiring Apple to provide access to encrypted user data, finding that the government had not shown disclosure would harm national security. The decision allows significant parts of legal challenges by Apple and privacy groups to proceed publicly, but does not determine whether the order itself is lawful.
The tribunal rejected the government’s argument that revealing the reported Technical Capability Notice would damage national security. The government had not previously confirmed the notice, which was issued under powers that restrict companies from disclosing such orders. The ruling permits public proceedings on the challenges, while the notice’s precise technical requirements remain undisclosed.
The government said the notice was intended to ensure authorities could access data for lawful investigations and protect public safety. A spokesperson said the powers were subject to safeguards and that the government did not have access to companies’ communications systems or data. The tribunal’s ruling addresses whether the order could remain secret, not the government’s stated...