Supreme Court Leaves UC Grant Ruling in Place
The Supreme Court on November 16 declined to hear the Trump administration’s appeal over research-grant cuts to University of California researchers, leaving in place a lower-court ruling that the terminations likely violated the First Amendment. The brief order gave no explanation, and no justice publicly dissented.
The case, Trump v. Thakur, concerns grants terminated after the administration sought to align federal funding with its policy priorities, including opposition to diversity, equity and inclusion initiatives. The lower courts found that the researchers were likely to prevail on claims that the grants were cut because of the perceived viewpoints expressed in their work. The Supreme Court’s refusal to review the case leaves that ruling in effect; it did not issue a new ruling on the constitutional question.
The administration has argued that the government has broad discretion to choose which research to fund, including projects that fit its priorities. In its appeal, Solicitor General D. John Sauer argued that the lower court’s First Amendment analysis could constrain the government’s authority over spending and grants. The dispute will continue in lower courts.