Fakhar Zaman's dismissal off Pandya sparks umpiring controversy

Hardik Pandya claimed the key early wicket of Fakhar Zaman as India bowled first and struck in the third over of the Asia Cup Super Four clash against Pakistan on September 21 at the Dubai International Cricket Stadium, but the dismissal sparked controversy after the onfield umpires referred the catch behind the stumps to the third umpire. The TV official ruled Fakhar out for 15 off nine balls, a decision that left the Pakistan camp visibly frustrated and prompted criticism from former players.

Pandya delivered an offcutter that induced a faint edge to wicketkeeper Sanju Samson. Samson dived low and appeared to hold the ball as Fakhar trudged back to the crease, but uncertainty over whether the ball had bounced or been fully secured led to a review. After examining replays, including close-ups, the third umpire adjudged the catch clean and gave Fakhar out. The decision reduced Pakistan to 21 for one and ended an aggressive start in which the left-hander had struck three boundaries.

Pakistan head coach Mike Hesson was visibly displeased with the outcome on the field, and former cricketers added their voices to the criticism. Shahid Afridi quipped on television that the decision...